What if this happened?

Hey guys and girls!

Last month, I saw that my good friend Tall Cactus made something called “What If?” and then Purple Claw did it too in response on his blog. And then Lucky Wing. And then Vampi. And guess who’s turn is it now? It’s mine!


What if the sponsored islands are different realms?

Hmm, maybe they could be different worlds! Interesting…

What if only the people on Home Island (and Mocktropica) know that they are in a game and everyone else is brainwashed?

Well… I guess everything could get strange and maybe I would be like, “What the cheese is going on?”

What if your Poptropican ran away from their parents to explore the world and is constantly hopping from island to island to not get caught?

Maybe. Or I’m not sure.

What if restarting islands erases everyone’s memories?

Interesting. Then maybe they don’t know why your character’s in the island?

What if Poptropica is just a dream?

Then I must have a nightmare or something.

What if the Booted Bandit is your Poptropican, but from an alternate future?

Then I guess he would probably be a thief than an explorer. Or I don’t know.

What if some of the islands don’t actually take place on islands, but on the mainland?

Maybe not.

What if some islands take place on the same landmass? Maybe even one, bigger island?

Oh my ZEUS. Maybe the game would be boring.

What if all the islands in Pop were already discovered and colonized, but you just dandy find them yet?

That’s tricky. I would have to just say yes…

What if all Poptropicans have realistic names, and players just have names like Tall Cactus to keep them safe online?

Yeah, they might literally have realistic names, but the website gives funny names to our characters.

What if there is some villain out there that glued everyone’s fingers together and to their hand so Poptropicans hands are stuck as circles? (this one was more of a joke question, lol)

Wh-what? Then this is going to be CRAZY!!! :O

What if Poptropica has a tropical name even though many islands aren’t even in the tropics is because the first islands discovered were, and they just kept the name? (for example, the ancient capital of Poptropolis was tropical)

Ehh… let’s say it’s just the name. Dunno what else to say.

What if those monkeys who made your climb in Monkey Wrench Island were actually people in costumes? (also a joke question)

I would probably say so, those monkeys were really smart, helped me get my blimp to finish that race. Or maybe they read something useful for them to become smart.

What if Dr. Hare isn’t actually a doctor/doesn’t have a real doctorate degree?

Well, he probably has a doctorate degree, but he started doing crazy evil things.

What if the Booted Bandit started the trend of Poptropicans wearing shoes in the upcoming New Pop?

I’m gonna have to say yes, he probably introduced shoes. Thanks, BB!

What if the New Pop answers all of these random questions, or more?

Then I guess everything would get weird. Or boring.

Aaaaaand that’s all for the “What if” post! One more thing to say:

Today when I came back from school, I noticed that Club Penguin was going to shut down this year. I know this is kinda sad, but fortunately Pop will still go on forever, we hope! 😀

Oh, and before I end this post, make sure to enter the Community Creations Contest on the PHB! I am currently drawing something for that contest, it’s in my sta.sh in my deviantART right now. Guess who I am shipping Cuddly with?

Here’s a hint:


If you can’t see the picture, let me know in the comments and I’ll fix it.

Anyways if you would like to do this “What if” thing on your blog, feel free to comment below. Don’t be shy. 😉

Well, I gotta go now, CK out!

-Cuddly Knuckle a.k.a Wilbur


13 thoughts on “What if this happened?

So... what d'ya think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s